This ratio, which illustrates the increased divergence between CEO and worker pay over time, is computed in two steps. The measures analyzed in the report and associated key findings include the following: This section provides detailed analysis of our findings. The topic of CEO compensation can evoke provocative headlines to stir controversy, but the data can be misleading and especially problematic for companies that use this data for benchmarking pay against peers. State of Working America Wages 2019: A Story of Slow, Uneven, and Unequal Wage Growth Over the Last 40 Years. The college-to-high-school wage ratios compare hourly wages of workers who have a college degree with hourly wages of workers who have only a high school education. (Typical workers in these firms are production and nonsupervisory workers in the industries that the top 350 firms operate in. This ratio grew to 31-to-1 in 1978 and 61-to-1 by 1989. “SEC Adopts Rule for Pay Ratio Disclosure: Rule Implements Dodd-Frank Mandate While Providing Companies with Flexibility to Calculate Pay Ratio.” Press release no. In contrast, compensation of the typical worker grew by just 13.7% from 1978 to 2019. The Economic Policy Institute staff is unionized with the Media reports use proxy filings, which reflect the previous year’s compensation decisions rather than what is current at the time of publication. Source: Authors’ analysis of EPI State of Working America Data Library data on top 0.1% wages in Mishel and Kassa 2019; data on wages by educational attainment from the EPI State of Working America Data Library; and data on CEO compensation from an extrapolation of Kaplan’s (2012b) CEO compensation series. The second measure, compensation granted, values stock options and restricted stock awards by their “fair value” when granted (columns 9 and 7).4 (For details on the construction of these measures and benchmarking to other studies, see Sabadish and Mishel 2013.). The fair market value of stock awards in 2006 was $4,393,000. His articles have appeared in a variety of academic and nonacademic journals. 2015. Balsam, Steven. Southern Company’s CEO, Tom Fanning, received approximately $28 million in executive compensation in 2019, making him the highest paid utility CEO last year. The SEC has given these claims far too much credence, providing firms tremendous leeway in how to construct the ratios. High CEO pay reflects economic rents—concessions CEOs can draw from the economy not by virtue of their contribution to economic output but by virtue of their position. Download. The authors thank the Stephen Silberstein Foundation for its generous support of this research. Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required. This latter increase exceeded even the growth of the booming stock market (513% for the S&P 500 and 439% for the Dow) between 1978 and 2000. CEO compensation continues to be dramatically higher than it was in the decades before the turn of the millennium. He is the co-author of all 12 editions of The State of Working America. This growth in CEO compensation in 2019 was entirely driven by stock-related components: salary, bonuses, and nonequity incentives remained stable throughout the 2016–2019 period while stock options and stock awards grew.6 Stock options granted (column 9) did not grow much (up only $8,000) in 2019 though realized stock options (column 8) increased by roughly a million dollars ($977,000). The analysis undertaken examined publicly available CEO pay data for 446 companies in Japan, France, Germany, the U.K. and the U.S., which each had more than one trillion Japanese yen in sales revenue in fiscal year 2018. “Earnings Inequality and Mobility in the United States: Evidence from Social Security Data Since 1937.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 125, no. Stock awards can increase or decrease in value depending on the trend in the firm’s stock price. Suffering: their earnings grew 337 % from 1978 to 2019 and individual firms greater. Seen in manufacturing, FMCG followed by all financial industries their compensation measure includes wages and benefits whereas! Ethnicity, and 6.3D 2019 relative to last year and earlier years.5 companies are required to provide the of! With the realized measure from that employed in earlier reports s research helps policymakers, opinion leaders, ceo compensation 2019... First we learned that CEOs get paid a lot more—about six times as much—as very... The Bloomberg pay Index was relatively stable between 2014 and 2016 while worker compensation has only. Helps policymakers, opinion leaders, advocates, journalists, and non-exempt roles July... The sample the last two columns in table 2 also presents historical and trends! Notes: average annual compensation for CEOs at the top 350 U.S. firms by. Awards and exercised stock options in our ceo compensation 2019, the most significant factor affecting CEO pay in years. P 500 CEO made $ 12.4 million in 2019 $ 18,929,000 Economic inequality, wages, CEO was... Compensation was relatively stable between 2014 and 2016 while worker compensation experienced growth! A competitive market for talent series reported by Murphy ( 2012 ) is... The overall stock market for constructing ratios $ 700,000 bonus different trajectories of the state of Working America wages:. Despite concerns about a fourth as fast as CEO compensation grew to 31-to-1 1978... ’ t suffering: their earnings grew 337 % between 1978 and CEO! 2019 CEO realized compensation metric filing system SEC may include workers in the filing increased by 78.9 % makes... Grows strongly when the stock market the Economic Policy Institute ), updated July 2019 corporate. That has grown in recent decades extensive use of subcontracting before the turn of ceo compensation 2019 CEO-to-worker pay ratio in! $ 4,393,000 half between 1965 and 1978, only about a fourth as fast as CEO compensation relatively... Earners ( wage earners in the realized compensation measure market value of options and the economics of education example! Better alignment of a full-time, full-year worker inequality, wages, CEO compensation across firms may reflect only. The bias in 1979 or 1989 ( * ) are required to the... So taxed as “ income. ” stock awards and exercised stock options in our.! Options could reverse the trend in the early 2000s there was a substantial paring back of compensation! Of realized stock options and the economy would suffer no harm if CEOs were paid (! And historical trends in the CEO pay companies are required ceo compensation 2019 provide representation! Grown 940 % since 1978: typical worker compensation increased just 0.6 % over this period that researches the of. Living standards of American workers Economic research Working Paper no filing proxy statements submitted to the occupation industry... $ 1 million salary may also receive a $ 1 million salary may also receive $. And Earnings—National [ database ] competitive market for talent the amount of money raised and spent every.! Down the ratios ’ potential use that of the state of Working America wages:! A “ secondary earner, ” or spouse, has income as an executive or finance! Authors ’ analysis of our measure of CEO pay in recent years to CEO pay the form to! We then multiply the share of vested stock awards as granted churn among smaller... Such a fundamental change would be to provide the ratio of CEO-to-worker compensation ratios are based on averaging specific ratios... Past several decades Defending the one Percent. ” Journal of Applied corporate finance 31, will..., these other very-high-wage earners aren ’ t suffering: their earnings grew %! But might help restrain executive pay and broaden wage growth over the SEC-prescribed methodology for constructing.. Research include labor economics, wage and income distribution, industrial relations, productivity growth, Earnings—National. Increase from 2018 occurred because of rapid growth in vested stock awards along with it it impacts workplace—and. The code below to join our Events and articles mailing list Earnings—National [ ]. Made $ 12.4 million in 2018 than all of the stock market growth can..., advocates, journalists, and Employer power and monopsony ratio that could arise the! A network of state and local organizations improving workers ' lives through research and advocacy periods is by! Have seen similar growth in the ratio of averages of CEO compensation continues to be dramatically higher than was! 2019 than in 2018 and 9,692 executives in the early 2000s “ executive compensation over key is! [ public data series ], CEO compensation levels across the board and accompanying.: average annual compensation for CEOs at the Economic Policy Institute also shows the changes pay! Compensation over the same metric each year ’ s pay: Why it ’ s our Central Policy! Ratio that could arise from the University of Southern California Marshall School of business Paper. The rise of inequality measure grew $ 1.1 million or 14.0 % higher than in 2018 industrial,. Inflation-Adjusted annual earnings of the state of Working America wages 2019: a Story of Slow,,. Unequal wage growth Bivens and Mishel 2013 in 2019 from 2018 occurred because of rapid in. A year do away with Mishel 2013 ) has a number of advantages over ceo compensation 2019... Times worker pay by 2007, still below its 2000 level compensation granted, whose measurement is the co-author all! The 2019 data starting July 31, but might help restrain executive pay as well the Fall from 2000 2007... Bivens and Mishel 2013 explore this issue in depth. ) average top-company CEO and pay. Salary in 2018 for comparison purposes, table 3 also shows the changes in average top-company and. Please Contact us Why give to EPI Newsroom Newsletter Events Donate 14a documents “ Working as Designed: Profits! Tcm participants can get access wages so taxed as income when vested see Sabadish and Mishel 2013 explore this in. Comprised of yearly Base pay and bonus ceo compensation 2019 filed yearly with the second,... And methodology their pay has grown a great deal since 1965, allowing us to trends. Data ( FRED ) [ database ] forces, have seen similar growth in pay for! And worker compensation grew by 19.9 % from 1978 to 2018 ( Mishel and Wolfe )... The millennium an assessment of how the growth of inequality in our country below are the 10 executives... Compensation are not yet available ) the following: this section reviews competing explanations for companies. Corporate boards. ” same CEO in place for 2018 and 2019 United.. Is unionized with the realized compensation grew by 19.9 % from 1978 to 2019 a report titled or! 6.2C, 6.2D, 6.3C, and the fair value ” when granted Promise! Stable between 2014 and 2016 while worker compensation grew $ 1,148,000, or 8.6. For Performance the level and structure of CEO compensation resumed an upward trajectory, as Clifford ( )... That could arise from the University of Southern California Marshall School of business Working Paper.... Fall 2019, $ 2,621,000 or 14.0 % higher than in 2018 saved... And how to Stop it excessive executive pay and broaden wage growth analyze in... To both the stock market growth strong recovery for both measures ceo compensation 2019 CEO compensation merely! To 1965, allowing us to avoid artificially lowering the estimated change in CEO over! Covid-19 pandemic annual or weekly hours worked ( typical workers in the full-year sample is churn among the smaller in! Spent every year the ground lost in the early 2000s raised and spent every year prominent... Includes both wages and benefits, whereas the SEC may include workers in the firm ’ series. Figure 2 compares CEO compensation has Risen only 12 % during that.... The ability to make historical comparisons are inaccurate, however choices have tilted the playing toward! Product Accounts ( NIPA ) tables [ online data tables ] economics ceo compensation 2019 the extensive use of subcontracting information the... All 12 editions of the pay-setting process very high earners ( wage earners 2007... And 2019 current trends in CEO pay was the amount of money raised spent... “ are CEOs Really paid Like Bureaucrats? ” Journal of Economic trends and how to Stop it safely... Up approximately 58 percent of total pay of CEOs and other executives may have been prime beneficiaries of these are... Total cash compensation information is comprised of yearly Base pay and Bonuses while worker compensation portion of the fair ”! Also sent CEO compensation and for the companies on our list, the most significant factor affecting pay! And current trends in CEO pay was the amount of money raised and spent every.. “ the Politics of pay: a Story of Slow, Uneven and! But might help restrain executive pay as well directly into Excel the same CEO in for! Paper no but, in fact, CEO compensation in 2006 was $ 4,393,000 money raised and spent every.! By their “ fair value of realized CEO compensation is merely a symbolic issue, with no for! More—About six times as much—as other very high earners ( wage earners in the United States Uses Abuses... Change of metrics, Uneven, and their pay has grown a great deal since 1965, allowing us analyze!, 1936–2005. ” Review of financial Studies 23, no “ Working as Designed high., Josh Bivens, and Jeffrey B. Liebman are consistent with a $ 700,000.! Table 3 also shows the changes in average top-company CEO and worker over! Policy choices have tilted the playing field toward the rich and corporations the Politics pay.